- Trading ships in Marque & Reprisal are defined by cargo capacity, crew needs, and propulsion type
- Cargo capacity is king, but never sacrifice food and water reserves for extra hold space
- Match the hull to the route: short regional loops and long spice runs need different vessels
- Permdeath applies to ships: a lost trader loses its cargo, crew, and captain progress together
- Upgrade after a route works, not before you have proven it can turn a profit
How Trading Ships Work in Marque & Reprisal
Every voyage in Marque & Reprisal is a single-ship, single-voyage challenge with permadeath consequences. A trading ship is therefore not just a cargo container: it is your lifeline, your warehouse, and your escape vehicle at the same time. Cargo capacity, crew requirements, cannon capacity, and propulsion determine whether a vessel suits commerce, exploration, fishing, or combat, so a trade-focused captain should evaluate hulls by role rather than by any single stat.
The core trade loop is straightforward. Compare what a port offers with what another destination needs, then account for supplies, cargo capacity, travel time, and the risk of losing the shipment before committing to a long route. Port demand is your primary source of trade direction: use local demand to decide where cargo should be sold instead of following a fixed route every time.
Every cargo slot you fill with goods is a slot not holding food and water. Treat the hold as a budget split between profit and survival, and reserve enough room for the full round trip, including delays, tacking, and storms.
The table below summarizes how the main hull roles compare for trade-focused captains.
| Hull Role | Priority Stats | Trade Value | Main Tradeoff |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cargo hauler | Cargo capacity, supply efficiency, crew needs | ★★★★★ | Weak at escaping hostile encounters |
| Exploration vessel | Propulsion, endurance, crew flexibility | ★★★☆☆ | Less profit per trip than a dedicated trader |
| Fishing platform | Working space, supply endurance | ★★★☆☆ | Inefficient for high-volume port trading |
| Combat privateer | Cannons, crew, mobility | ★★☆☆☆ | Combat gear consumes space and funds |
Core Trade Commodities and Cargo Planning
The main money-makers for trading voyages are spices, fish, and whale oil, and each fits a different voyage profile. Judge every cargo by margin per cargo space, not by sticker price at the dock.
| Commodity | Role | Best Use | Risk Profile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spices | High-value cargo | Strong demand destinations with adequate reserves | Distance and hostile encounters can erase the margin |
| Fish | Trade good and voyage support | Short regional trades or fishing-friendly routes | Low value becomes inefficient over long distances |
| Whale oil | Specialized long-distance cargo | Routes where capacity and demand justify commitment | Long exposure to supply depletion and navigation errors |
| Port demand intel | Trade direction | Deciding where to sell instead of fixed routes | Demand can shift and devalue a planned destination |
| Cargo capacity | Expansion constraint | Increase only after a reliable loop exists | Overloading leaves too little room for survival resources |
Short Regional Loop
- Fish and light goods
- Frequent resupply stops
- Low risk, steady income
- Ideal for new captains
Spice Run
- High margin per slot
- Requires wind planning
- Hostile traffic exposure
- Best with proven reserves
Whale Oil Route
- Long-distance commitment
- Large hold required
- Highest supply pressure
- Reserve-heavy loadout
A route that looks short on the map can become expensive when repeated tacking is required. Distance, wind, and weather multiply consumption, and a voyage that reaches its destination with no reserve can still be fatal on the return leg.
Step-by-Step: Building a Profitable Trade Voyage
Scout demand before buying
Compare cargo availability at your current port with demand at the intended destination. Record profitable pairings so future voyages can reuse proven loops instead of guessing each time.
Split the hold between cargo and supplies
Load food and water for the full round trip plus a buffer for tacking, weather delays, and detours. Only then fill the remaining space with the highest-margin cargo that fits.
Plan the route around wind and ports
Check whether the destination lies upwind, downwind, or across the prevailing wind. Favor routes with intermediate harbors when supplies are limited, even if they add map distance.
Execute and monitor reserves
Watch consumption against your planned reserve. If supplies fall below the route reserve before the destination, divert to the nearest practical port rather than pushing on.
Return and reinvest deliberately
Bank the profit, then upgrade cargo capacity, crew, or gear for a defined purpose. Permdeath makes reliable routines more valuable than reckless growth.
A successful trade voyage is one that returns safely with supplies, cargo, and progress intact. Extending a profitable trip into a dangerous one merely to chase one more port is the most common way traders lose everything.
Surviving Hostile Waters as a Trader
Combat is not required for a successful trading campaign. Trade, fishing, and exploration-focused voyages can avoid unnecessary engagements, and for a loaded trader, avoidance is almost always the correct call.
- Identify hostile ships early and change course before committing to an engagement
- Treat damage and lost time as part of the true cost of any victory
- Use coastal routes with frequent ports to reduce exposure to hostile traffic
- A license does not make every target legal: unlicensed attacks create broader diplomatic problems with the 28 empires, which can close ports to your trade routes
| Situation | Recommended Action |
|---|---|
| Loaded with high-value cargo | Avoid or outrun; do not engage |
| Light cargo, near friendly ports | Discretionary; minor fights acceptable |
| Hostile ship on your trade lane | Re-route via alternate ports |
| Supplies running low | Head to nearest harbor, skip optional stops |
A profitable encounter can become strategically costly if it damages relations with an empire that controls important ports, routes, or future opportunities. Review the political context before any hostile action.
Trader's Pre-Departure Checklist
Before You Sail:
- Confirmed destination demand for your cargo
- Food and water reserved for the full round trip
- Wind direction checked against the planned route
- Fallback port identified for each exposed stretch
- Cargo margin per slot calculated against travel cost
Upgrade cargo capacity only after you can complete a route consistently. Investments made before a loop is proven are the fastest way to lose a ship to permadeath.
Trading Ship FAQ
Q: What makes a ship a good trading ship in Marque & Reprisal?
Cargo capacity, supply efficiency, and manageable crew requirements. A dedicated trader maximizes profitable cargo while keeping enough capacity for food and water, accepting reduced flexibility against hostile encounters.
Q: Should I fill the hold completely with cargo?
No. Reserve hold space for food and water covering the full round trip plus a buffer for tacking, storms, and detours. Every cargo slot filled with goods is a slot unavailable for survival.
Q: Is combat required for trading voyages?
No. Trade, fishing, and exploration-focused voyages can avoid unnecessary combat. Route changes, coastal sailing, and distance let traders skip fights that do not serve the voyage.
Q: Which commodity is best for new traders?
Fish and light regional goods. They suit short loops with frequent resupply, letting you learn port demand, wind management, and supply planning before committing to long spice or whale oil runs.
Q: When should I upgrade to a larger trading ship?
Upgrade only after you complete a repeatable route consistently. Balance additional cargo space against the food, water, crew, and safety needs of the larger voyage, and keep funds for supplies after expansion.